I got this great idea from a friend of mine. It's GENIUS!
You know when you have a pinata at a kids' birthday party and the scramble after leaves some kids with a stash and others in tears?
Before stuffing the pinata with candy, put the candy in little baggies. You could even put kids' names on them to make the scramble interesting. :) Every child gets the same amount of candy and all is fair. No tears!